Regulatory Issues

Written on: November 1, 2025 by Doug Raymond

CARB needs your survey response
On Sept. 8, 2025, the California Air Resources Board (CARB) held a webinar on the current status of the 2023 Consumer Products Survey. To reiterate, CARB is surveying Industry on 37 product categories that will likely be the focus of its next rulemaking. Seventeen categories are to be the focus of volatile organic compound (VOC) reductions, 19 categories will be reviewed for parachlorobenzotrifluoride (PCBTF) prohibition and one category reviewed due to U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regulation. All 37 categories could be used for VOC reduction, but that may not be the case. CARB will evaluate all the survey data on these product categories.

There is a problem: Industry is not responding to the survey, and that was the reason for the webinar in September. April 8, 2025, was the original deadline for all surveys to be completed and submitted to CARB. CARB compared current responses to the 2023 survey of the 37 product categories to the previous 2013–2015 survey results in the same 37 product categories and found mass underreporting.

CARB results show that for 2023, there were 417 companies that reported on the 37 product categories compared to 894 companies that reported in 2013–2015. We know that some products are removed from sale and some companies have gone out of business, but CARB estimates that 574 companies are non-responders. CARB removed all companies that were no longer in business, changed their names or were bought and under a new company name and still, there is a large number of non-responding companies.

CARB detailed the responses for each product category. For example, General Purpose Cleaner (non-aerosol) has around 150 fewer companies reporting in 2023. The Hand & Body Conditioner, Cream, Lotion & Moisturizer category had approximately 250 fewer companies reporting in 2023.

This is a poor showing by Industry and will ultimately impact how the rule is developed; from past experiences, I know that this lack of reporting will affect Industry negatively.

Some may ask, with this being a mandatory survey, why not have CARB enforcement fine non-respondents? Personally, I do not believe dealing with fines would be a good use of CARB’s time or Industry’s time. A better use of our resources would be to monitor and police our own Industry. I am requesting that everyone go to the CARB website and review the non-respondent list. Even though the new deadline was Sept. 22, 2025, any new survey data added will help.

Non-respondent scenario
This is what happens if you do not submit data: The current data is collected and combined. Data will show an average VOC value or, more than likely, an average maximum incremental reactivity (MIR) value. CARB then decides to set its new limit at the average. Your company reviews this data, and your product is shown as higher than the average—but you had never reported that the average is actually lower. So, you go to CARB and say, “Hey wait! We need a higher limit!” while also explaining that you never submitted your survey. Guess what CARB will say? Likely nothing positive.

Therefore, once again, I ask you to please submit information on this survey.

Below is the current timeline for this next rulemaking. Most of Industry work will begin in January 2026.

Timeline
Survey
• Dec. 3, 2024: Survey launch
• April 8, 2025: Deadline for submitting completed survey data for both responsible party (RP) and formulators
• Sept. 22, 2025: New reporting deadline
• Early October 2025: Preliminary identification of categories with persistent under-reporting
• Late October 2025: Complete quality assurance/quality control (QA/QC) of additional submittals from extended deadline

Regulatory
• Mid January 2026: Initiate remediation of category reporting shortfalls
• Late January 2026: Draft survey data summary; workshop for stakeholder input
• January 2026: 2023 survey data summary release and total organic gases (TOG) list
• Late February 2026: Update survey category regulatory inventory
• March–May 2026: Pre-regulatory category evaluation and stakeholder webinars/workshops
• Late December 2026: Consolidate category regulatory strategies and prepare Initial Statement of Reason (ISOR)
• Late October 2027: Regulatory Amendment Board hearing

To contact CARB, visit here or email 2023CPSurvey@arb.ca.gov . Put “Live help” in the subject line and include a phone number or e-mail where you can be reached.

New Jersey
As a reminder, New Jersey has updated its Consumer Product Regulation on VOCs from Ozone Transport Commission (OTC) Model Rule II to OTC Model Rule IV. It will become effective on Aug. 18, 2026. SPRAY